Comparing Traditional Shingles vs. Impact-Resistant Shingles

Comparing Traditional Shingles vs. Impact-Resistant Shingles

June 29, 20252 min read

Choosing the right material for your roof is a major decision, directly affecting your home's protection, longevity, and even your insurance premiums. At Burt Chandler Company Inc., the best roofing company in Dallas, we provide our clients with clear information to make the best choice for their properties. Let's look closely at how traditional asphalt shingles stack up against advanced impact-resistant shingles.

Get a Quote

Comparison showing a cracked traditional shingle next to an undamaged impact-resistant shingle after impact.

Resistance to Damage

Traditional asphalt shingles provide a standard level of protection against typical weather conditions. They are generally resilient to moderate wind and rain. However, when faced with severe impacts, particularly from hail, they can be vulnerable to cracking, bruising, or granule loss. In contrast, impact-resistant shingles are engineered with enhanced materials, often incorporating modified asphalt or rubberized polymers. This specialized composition allows them to absorb significant impact energy, flexing rather than fracturing.

Curling and cracked roof shingles

Longevity Expectations

The lifespan of any roof is influenced by many factors, including installation quality, climate, and maintenance. Generally, traditional asphalt shingles have a life expectancy of 15-25 years. Because impact-resistant shingles are built with superior durability, their inherent resistance to damage from impacts and harsh weather often translates to a longer overall lifespan, potentially extending to 30 years or more. This added resilience means your roof may require fewer repairs.

Homeowner smiling next to a strong roof, with visuals indicating reduced insurance premiums and fewer claims.

Impact on Insurance Premiums and Claims

This is where the distinction becomes particularly important for homeowners today. With rising insurance rates a constant concern, preventing claims is paramount. Traditional shingles, being more susceptible to hail damage, can lead to frequent roof insurance claims after severe storms. Impact-resistant shingles, due to their certified durability, are often recognized by insurance providers. At Burt Chandler Company Inc., we provide a free upgrade to our "Smart Roof" (which uses these impact-resistant shingles) at the same cost as a traditional shingle roof. This upgrade can reduce your insurance premiums and significantly decreases the likelihood of needing to file a claim at all after many weather events.

Roofer nailing in new shingles

Upfront Cost Versus Long-Term Value

Historically, impact-resistant shingles carried a higher upfront cost than traditional shingles. While this remains generally true in the broader market, Burt Chandler Company Inc. has made this advanced protection accessible. As leading roofing contractors, we provide our Smart Roof featuring impact-resistant shingles at the same cost as a standard shingle roof. This means you gain the benefits of superior durability and potential insurance savings without an additional initial investment.

Make the wise choice for your home’s lasting protection. Get your free Smart Roof upgrade with Burt Chandler Company Inc. today!

Get a Quote

Back to Blog

With rising insurance rates, protecting your roof has never been more important. Choose Burt Chandler Company Inc. for impact-resistant shingles, at no additional cost. This reduces future claims and insurance premiums, and our team handles all your insurance claim work for you.

©2025 Burt Chandler Company - All rights reserved